Cimaroli's Supper Club

Cimaroli's Supper Club, nestled in Portage, WI, is quickly becoming a beloved destination for steak enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Patrons rave about the Flat Iron steak, highlighting its perfect cooking and rich flavor. Jordan Pekar's experience echoes this sentiment, declaring it the best he's had in ages. The establishment is celebrated not just for its steaks but also for its charming atmosphere and attentive service. Shenan Gilleland remarked on how the staff makes everyone feel like a regular, underscoring the warmth you can expect during your visit.

Moreover, the onion loaf has received high praise, with Spencer Stone claiming it's “to die for,” a testament to the kitchen's ability to deliver comfort food that leaves a lasting impression. Complemented by perfectly crafted cocktails, including their famed Old Fashioneds, it's no wonder guests like Galen Davis choose Cimaroli's for special occasions like birthdays.

While there are minor critiques, such as the saltiness in certain sauces, the overall consensus is clear: Cimaroli's Supper Club stands out as a top-notch dining experience in the area. With its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, it's a place where culinary excellence meets a welcoming atmosphere. Plan your visit for a memorable meal that will leave you yearning for more.